As a web developer I was always intrigued to learn more about mobile app development. Unfortunately, my early attempts with my first smartphone - a Palm Pre running Web OS - suffered from company politics and I decided to stop developing apps for an awesome but abandoned platform. So here I am - roughly two years later - contemplating to buy a new smartphone.
While my Pre Plus is still working the lack of apps and slow demise of the underpowered hardware became too annoying. For a change, I didn't want to go with an underdog and ended up ordering a Motorola Razr i. While waiting for the shipment to arrive I started writing my first app for Android 4. The first lesson I learnt is that looking after a wailing baby leaves little time and less focus to get anything done on top of that.
Then there's Java - an old acquaintance from more than a decade ago. I never liked it, never hated it either, but I've always been put off by the enterprise nature of everything surrounding it. It's also one of the few languages that requires an IDE. After a few hours trying to put together the simplest Android app with vim and a console and failing to figure out simple things like where to import classes from I installed Eclipse.
I must admit Eclipse does not suck as much as it used to (as in the room's light bulbs do not dim anymore when you fire it up). With Eclipse things got more fluent and I especially liked the way the UI designer works and keeps you at a safe distance from XML. I must admit I haven't used a visual UI designer that actually worked since Delphi 4. Everything was going well until it came to persisting structured data. You would assume that in 2013 a smartphone with its abundance of sensors has an OS that makes aggregating and sharing that data as easy as possible. So how do you store structured data? Easy: Just use sqlite and implement DAOs for your tables. It's as easy as that. Seriously, I feel like someone has given me the latest Makita multitool and just a bunch of nails and expects me to build some awesome stuff with that.
Maybe I spent too much time with web frameworks like TurboGears and Django but reinventing (shitty) ORMs for every app I write is not something I want to do in my free time. Scratch that: I don't want to do that at all. And this is just for storing data locally. I probably want to sync that data to the cloud, a web application or other devices later on.
Maybe I should just save data to a remote web application? The question then is: Why bother with a mobile app at all? Sounds like pouring your time into making one web app work well with mobile devices is time better spent than implementing about four different apps for the currently relevant mobile platforms. Plus this gives you the option to use your favorite language and best available technology to implement the web app.
That sounds like a good idea until you want to make the app work in offline mode or with low latency in the outback of Brandenburg (make that Wyoming if you're in the US). Then building a dedicated app is the only option but can be limited to the features that are relevant in these usage scenarios, e.g. gathering data like miles walked through the woods or number of diapers changed can be logged in the mobile app but displaying statistics can be restricted to the web application. That's what apps like Baby Connect seem to do (yes, that's the most interesting app for me right now). I'm just amazed on what kind of libraries these things are built on.
IMHO it doesn't have to be that complicated. Android could sync CSV data to a Google Drive spreadsheet which would make sharing data with different devices easy and wouldn't require a dedicated web application.
One could also let apps connect to a pre-installed SQL database running on the device and make a light-weight ORM part of the standard library. This wouldn't solve the problem of syncing the data to a remote server but wouldn't require ridiculous amounts of code to solve simple problems.
Ultimately I could also imagine having a distributed database node (let's say Riak) on the device and which would allow syncing with remote nodes.
Do I ask for too much? Maybe that's already possible in Android and I just didn't get it? Or maybe the grass is greener on the other side and these things have been solved in iOS, Windows Mobile or BlackBerry?